Top 10 Best Pizza Pans 2020 Reviews & Buying Guide

Who do not love pizza? In fact, no other dish enjoys the popularity that the delicious pizza has. Making a delicious pizza requires high-end pan with which you can prepare any flavors at the comfort of your home. Whether you are making pizzeria or homemade pizza, having the high-end pizza pan will help you create that perfect restaurant style pizza. Every type of pizza pan contributes to great build quality and is innovative its own way.

Regular pizza pan and pizza disk are the most common types of pizza pans. Besides, you can try different pans like deep-dish pizza pans, oven ready disposable pizza pans, CAR pans, cast iron pans, wide rim pizza pans etc. pizza stones, pizza disks & pizza screens are associated with the pizza pans. Whether you need a soft thin crust or doughy crust, a high-quality pizza pans meet your cooking needs. There are different types of pizza pans available on the market. So, if you are planning to buy a pizza pan checkout our top 10 picks of Best Pizza pans. You might also like to check Pizza peel reviews.

Best Buy Pizza Pans Reviews 2020

Table of Contents

1. Lodge P14P3Pro-Logic Pizza Pan

Lodge P14P3Pro-Logic Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

With loads of features, Lodge p14p3 pro – logic pan is considered as the top pick for our list. It is a sturdy pizza pan, which is easily available at major online shopping portals. The whole set of product is made of cast iron and is safe & spacious. Without having to worry about the storage facility, you can get this one at an affordable price. A strong flat base ensures durability and longevity. The unique and ergonomically designed handle gives you a comfortable feeling while working with it. The light and weightless pan promotes east transportation & maneuvering. Since the pan comes in 14 inches, it can be handy and comfortable.


  • Cool touch handle
  • Unique design
  • Easy transportation
  • Just 14 inch

2. ProBake Teflon Platinum Pizza Pan

ProBake Teflon Platinum Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

Next to our top pick, ProBake Teflon Platinum pizza pan is ideal for making a delicious pizza of different flavors. You just require 16-inch cooking space to add charm to your kitchen. One of the important features that a pan requires is durability and product quality. Thanks to the unique design of pro Bake product, which ensures scratch resistant and corrosion resistant pan. Interestingly, the pan is formulated with non-stick coating & heavy-duty steel construction, which makes sure that the heat is distributed evenly throughout the cooking surface. The cool touch handle is dishwater safe, thus you can toss in dishwater after use.

3. Cuisinart AMB-14PP Classic Chef’s Pizza Pan

Cuisinart AMB-14PP Classic Chef’s Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

You might have seen various kitchen accessories of Cuisinart that you use every single day. When it comes to making mouthwatering pizza, you can seek the help of Cuisinart to add culinary art to your pizza. Having this Cuisinart product makes your pizza job much easier. The stylish design and sleek handle make the Cuisinart product stands at the third place on the list. While people looking for a plastic handle, some prefer a durable pan that features aluminum steel constructions.


  • Aluminum construction
  • Unique design
  • Stylish handle
  • Affordable

4. AirBake Nonstick Pizza Pan

AirBake Nonstick Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

Not all good-looking pans have good build quality, so you have to look at hidden features also. AirBake nonstick pizza pan promotes good build quality along with a variety of attractive features. The perforated & stamped nonstick coating help reduce the cooking time. Besides having a perforated cooking surface, Air bake pizza pan boasts micro dome technology, which can reduce the cooking time by 15%. The pizza pan can withstand heat up to 425 F. The nonstick pizza pan comes with dishwasher parts. The price tag and versatile features make this AirBake pan a worthy purchase.


  • Perforated cooking surface
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Time Saver
  • 10-year manufacturer warranty

5. Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan

Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

Whether it is sliced onion pizza, vegetable pizza, chicken pizza or any other pizza, Chicago Metallic Pizza pan has an ability to create that delicious Chicago style dish pizza. When it comes to building quality, functionality, durability or convenience, this versatile Chicago product is perfectly designed to meet all your cooking needs. The aluminum steel construction ensures durability & scratch resistant. Besides being durable, it is formulated with a high-quality food grade material that helps prevent the pan from corrosion & wrapping.


  • Nonstick bake ware
  • Durable & strong
  • Prevent wrapping

6. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set

Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set

Buy From Amazon

Most people prefer buying inexpensive pizza pan but it did not fare well making delicious, evenly chopped pizzas, which might end up waste of time. Hence, it is advised not to consider only the price but try to look for the must-have features like limited warranty, durability, strong handle etc. A must-have food grade accessory can evenly distribute heat. It is a set of four mini pizza sets, which is ideal for sleepovers or making family pizza. Each mini pizza pan measures 7 inches, which makes it perfect for single serving. Since the base of the pan is perforated, it prevents wrapping, soggy crusts etc. The heavy gauge steel construction ensures even heat distribution. The non-stick cooking surface absorbs excess oil and eliminates broken pizza as well. It can withstand heat up to 500 F.


  • Heavy-duty steel
  • Exclusive lifetime warranty
  • Perfect Heat Resistant

7. Calphalon Bakeware 13-inch Pizza Pan

Calphalon Bakeware

Buy From Amazon

Yet another product from the same brand, these offers exclusive manufacturer warranty with loads of attractive features. The best part of the product is that it can withstand heavy temperature and the non-stick coat would not peel or crack even under high pressure. In addition to the heat-resistant materials, it boasts an advanced interlocking system that lets easy and safe storage.

The Caphalon product is perfectly designed to bake large pizza of 13 inches. It contains heavy-duty steel material, which can perform without wrapping or losing shape. The cooking surface can heat up the heavy temperature and promotes evenly baked pizzas. The Bakeware is designed in such a way that it has no harmful chemicals. It comes with a lifetime warranty.


  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Safe storage
  • No harmful chemicals
  • Dishwasher safe

8. OvenStuff Personal Size Non-Stick Pizza Pan

OvenStuff Personal Size Non-Stick Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

Ovenstuffs comes with the two set of pizza pans, which provide great build quality. Whether it is for personal or professional use, ovenstuff is ideal. These versatile pizza pans are designed using durable heavy steel, which ensures not just durability but also strong enough to render their quality after frequent use. The base material can heat pizzas quickly and saves your time. Since it is lightweight and compatible, Consumer finds the pizza pan easy to use and easy to hold.


  • Enable Effortless cooking
  • Great build quality
  • Durable heavy steel

9. Wilton Recipe Right Pizza Pans

Wilton Recipe Right Pizza Pans

Buy From Amazon

If you would be interested in buying the best pizza pan that can provide good performance without costing you much, Wilton pizza is what you are looking for. Wilton Pizza pan comes with the set of 2 pizza pans that are designed using heavy duty steel material to ensures durability. You just need 12 inches cooking space to store your perforated cooking accessory. The price tag and build quality enable everyone to afford the product. The nonstick layer eliminates broken pizza part and help make pizza as large as 12 inches. Although Wilton pan is inexpensive, the build quality and useful features enable effortless cooking.


  • Simple & affordable product
  • Easy to use
  • Dishwasher safe

10. Wilton Pizza Pan

Wilton Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

You might be amazed to have the Wilton pizza pan on the bottom of the list, but this versatile product is specially designed for anyone that wants to make fresh pizza at the comfort of his   home. It comes with 14 different mini pizza pans and each pan measures one inch in diameter. The pizza pan is formulated with a high-grade pan that won’t warp or rust over the time. The corrosion resistant pizza pan features cool touch handle and is available at affordable price. Similar to its previous product, Wilton right pizza pan is lightweight, compatible and handy.


  • Five-year warranty
  • Affordable
  • Durable

There are different types of pizza available in the market and each type of pan creates different types of pizza. These pizza pans are not just limited to the commercial pizza oven but can be used for a variety of dishes.

How To Choose The Best Pizza Pan

Pizza Pans Buying Guide
Pizza Pan has an important role to play in making a Pizza. It actually means the difference between a soggy bottomed pizza and a crisp crust pizza.  There are different types of Piazza pans that are made of different types of materials too.

The types of pan include

  • Tray/coup e– They are almost like trays except that they have a rounded rim. These trays are easy to handle and can be removed from the oven and placed for serving immediately.
  • Pizza Screens – They resemble the flat mesh disks that are used for baking. The Pizza screen would help you get an evenly baked crust. Since it allows heat to pass through, you will get a cooked pizza faster.
  • Deep dish pans – These pans are meant to cook pizzas that have a crunchy bottom but a softer and chewier inside. The pan is deeper than the traditional pizza pans, almost like a cake baking dish.
  • Pizza stones – These stones have to be preheated and used to get a pizzeria style pizza made at home.  The pizza that is produced is akin to the pizzas you get from a wood-fired oven with a crispy crust.

Choose the type of pan depending on the type of pizza that your family enjoys or choose one that you would be able to handle comfortably.

Styles of Pans

Like the types, the style of pans to seems to influence the type of pizza you can expect. The styles and how they influence the making of Pizza is as follows

  • Solid – This includes most of the types of pans as well as the pizza stone mentioned above. When you use solid pans, the cooking time is generally very long. This is because it takes time for the heat to pass through the solid metal to cook the pizza. The pizza you get when you use solid pans are generally chewier and they have a soft crust.
  • Perforated – The perforated pans are those that come with small holes throughout the pan. The holes in the pan prevent the crust from getting soggy even after resting because the moisture escapes through the holes and the movement of air that is possible because the perforation makes the Pizza crispier.
  • Super-perforated – These pans have larger holes than the standard pans and they yield crispy crusted pizza.
  • Nibbed – These pans have raised bumps. They are at the bottom of the pan. This helps raise the pizza from the surface of the pan and prevents grease and moisture accumulation at the bottom of the pan. This prevents the crust from becoming soggy and helps you to get a pizza with a crispier crust.

Choose the style that would be right for you. perforated pans are preferred over solid pans if you intend t get a crispy crust.

The color of the pan

Dark pans are preferred over the silver-colored pans. The reason being that the toppings on the pizza act somewhat like insulators and the Pizza has to be coked with the heat from the bottom. The silver colored pans reflect heat and slow down the cooking process while the dark colored pans retain heat and speed up the cooking.

The weight of the pan

Pans that are heavy are believed to produce evenly cooked crust pizza while those that are thin do produce crispy crust but not quite as good as the heavy pans.

 Pizza Pan Cleaning and Caring Instructions 

Cleaning an aluminum pan

Cleaning immediately after use with a mild liquid soap would suffice. If it has accumulated grease and baked on messes, you may follow the following steps.

  1. Add 2 cups of white vinegar to a gallon of water.
  2. Bring it to a boil
  3. Plug the sink so that water does not drain and fill it with the water.
  4. Add the pan to the solution. Keep twirling it in the water to ensure that the entire surface is soaked.
  5. When the water is cool sprinkle baking powder on the pa. you will notice a fizzing reaction. It would dissipate shortly. The vinegar would have loosened the grease while the baking powder would clear away the residue.
  6. You may repeat the process if required.

 How Can You Cook with a Pizza Pan with Holes? 

If you want to cook pizza in a pan with holes, then you need to spray the perforated pizza by using nonstick spray and you can also use oil instead of it. The oil like canola and olive can enhance the nutrition in pizza. After which you need to roll up the pizza into a thin layer. You can choose the thickness of pizza according to your taste. After this, you can sprinkle dough along with rolling pin with dry flour. You need to make sure that you don’t let the dough stick on the pan.  If your dough is made with whole wheat, then you will get better dietary fiber in your food. The digestion is improved in your body and it will ultimately reduce heart risks.

Laying out the pizza on a pan

You can lay the pizza crust on the pan and make sure that you keep the edges of pizza crust on pan. Make sure that the edges don’t hang over the pan area otherwise you won’t get evenly cooked pizza. The pizza can get burnt if the edges are hanging out of the pan. You can use a spatula to lay out the pizza on pan otherwise you must be knowing really easy ways to do it. It is not really difficult to do this procedure because beginners can also do it easily.

Baking pizza

You need to bake the crust just according to your recipe instructions and then you can use your favorite toppings on it. Make sure that you use low-fat oil or cheese, tomatoes, spinach, black olives, turkey meat, bell peppers, and other healthy toppings so that you can eat a healthy pizza. Make sure that you don’t overheat the pizza in the oven otherwise it might not taste good to you. You need to keep the optimum temperature according to the crust of your pizza. 

Heat the leftover pizza again

If you aren’t able to eat the whole pizza at once, then you can heat it on the perforated pan. You can lay the cold pizza on it and then you can bake it in the oven until it gets hot. If you will use the perforated pan, then the pizza would have a crispy crust. All you need is to have cooking oil, flour, pizza dough, pizza toppings along with a rolling pin. If you want to make the pizza tastier, then you can sprinkle the pizza with dried herbs and then you can top it up with sauce. These herbs can boost the natural value of pie and the flavor would also get improved due to it.

What you shouldn’t do

When you will use the perforated pan to make pizza, then you need to make sure that you don’t use the fatty cheese and pepperoni on it.  Make sure that you only use healthy ingredients to make the most delicious pizza. This would help you to stay healthy even when you are eating pizza which most of people consider as unhealthy food.

Pizza Pans vs. Pizza Screens: Which is better?

Pizza Pans:

Pizza Pans are available in different surface styles such as solid, perforated, super-perforated, etc. Such surface styles play an important role in providing heat distribution for cooking the pizzas. There are two types of pizza pans such as coupe-style pans and deep dishpans. Coupe style pans may either have a round rim style or square rim style. But it is easier to handle the cooking inside round-rim counterparts. Another advantage of using a coupe pan is that you can use the pan directly to cook inside the oven and use the same for serving the people.


  • Most of the homemakers prefer the regular coupe pans for cooking.
  • Most people prefer this pizza pan for its simplicity and durability.
  • It is easier to serve the pizza without creating any messy residue using coupe pans.
  • There is no need to transfer the cooked pizza to another tray for serving it, as you can use the same tray.


  • As the pan is made of aluminum, repeated use of the pans may result in the thin and soft surface of the pan. One has to change the hard-coat anodized aluminum frequently.
  • It allows less ventilation for cooking the pizza.

Pizza Screens:

To enjoy the faster bake time, go with the pizza screens for cooking pizzas. To retain the crunchiness of the pizza, this screen serves as the best option. They are light-weight when compared to pans, as they are constructed out of thin aluminum. Most of the pizza screens range from 6 to 28 inches in dimension. Here too rectangular pizza screens are less common in usage. As the pizza screen uses mesh construction, it allows for fast baking of the pizza with crispy finishes.


  • To retain the crunchiness of the crust in pizzas, the pizza screen serves as the best option.
  • It has a light-weight design and bakes faster.


  • After cooking the pizzas, one has to transfer the pie to the serving tray.
  • One can’t cut the pie on the pizza screen, as the topping may fall through the holes.

Pizza Pans vs. Pizza Screens: Which is better?

When comparing the pizza pans with pizza screens, it is given that both have equal advantages and disadvantages. To get faster baking, pizza screens are best and to serve the pizzas without any mess, pizza pans are best. Thus, you can buy any one of the above products but ensure that you check the quality before buying it.

Finally, I would say choose the best one of your choice.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.